| RailXpert | Why are we self-defeatists in indigenous mass transportation? - Moneylife on : September 11, 2013 - 04:00:03 AM |
|
Konkan Railway’s Sky Bus Technology was dumped on safety considerations while Mumbai Mono Rail is getting delayed due to safety concerns. Even, imported technology Monorail that costs 70% more than the Skybus, is being given preference. Why are we so defeatists towards not adopting Indian innovations? Engineering innovations such as Konkan Railway’s Sky Bus Technology, costing one-fourth the elevated Metro Rail, is dumped on safety considerations while safety concerns are causing delays in commissioning of Mumbai Monorail. The imported monorail technology, which costs 70% more than the Sky Bus, has been given preference (over Skybus) despite its capacity being barely one seventh of the indigenous Sky Bus capacity. Why are we so defeatists towards not adopting Indian innovations? Newspapers reports on 6 September 2013... “Monorail likely to be delayed further, contractors pulled up” … Hindustan Times “Chembur Wadala Monorail Unsafe: MMRDA Officials” … DNA “MMRDA raises doubts over monorail safety” … Times of India “Madan (Metropolitan Commissioner, MMRDA) spoke about the lack of safety on the monorail while referring to last month’s incident of a panel door falling. Additional commissioner Bhide said that since the monorail was in its first phase (from Chembur to Wadala), there was ample space below, luckily, no one was hurt. The case would have been different if it was in phase 2 – from Wadala to Saata Rasta – where the stretch below is narrow and crowded.” … Mumbai Mirror Scene: end September 2004, location Madgao, Goa. Venue: Test track of Sky Bus Metro, the innovative mode of transport of Konkan Railway. “Onboard staff has accidental fall from 6m height from the Sky Bus on a test run, meets fatal end.” This was the news headline at that time. Further testing was totally halted by the investigating agency. The innovator and team leader is not given extension to bring the Sky Bus Technology to logical conclusion. Ministry of Urban Development appoint an expert’s committee comprising of engineers, some from the Railways, including commissioner of Railway Safety and some from Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, competitors to Sky Bus technology, to see the viability of Sky Bus Metro. The expert’s committee was chaired by Prof Indiresan, former director of IIT Madras. It recommended to the Ministry to invest Rs50 crore to improve certain aspects of design over a period of two years. About Rs50 crore were already spent by industry partners with Konkan Railway for the test track and an additional Rs50 crore would have been very useful in terms of getting the Sky Bus Technology off the ground had Prof Indiresan recommended that the full amount be made available for spending immediately, with outer limit of two years. This kind of recommendation would have helped in giving Indian innovators the signal that government of India is serious in research and development (R&D) that would benefit our nation through indigenous innovations. The author even spent some time with Dr Mashelkar, the then director general of Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) discussing the Sky Bus innovation of B Rajaram, the then managing director of Konkan Railway. CSIR was sitting with funds as much as Rs5,000 crore for R&D then. Perhaps Dr Mashelkar, the advocate of “Gandhian Engineering—Maximum benefit to Maximum number of people with minimum expenditure” failed to recognize such an innovation could compete with the monorail and Metro Rails, with some additional benefits thrown in. Perhaps CSIR did not cover “technological innovations”. There have been fatal accidents in the construction phase of Mumbai Metro as well as Mumbai monorail. Falling of the door of a monorail could have happened in habited areas of the route and would have had, on its record, some deaths too. It was just a coincidence that it fell on an empty road. Having stopped further testing for three months in the case of Sky Bus, should not the government have stopped construction or testing of monorail or Metro Rail? Delhi Metro too has had its share of accidents, and not to speak of 3,600 people losing their lives every year on the suburban railway in Mumbai. Are we not self-defeatists that we allowed the Konkan Railways team of enthusiastic and energised engineers disperse to their respective parent railways, and that we allowed the test track and the rail coach lie idle in Goa to get rusted? While about 3,600 people get killed every year on the Mumbai suburban railway system, mainly due to heavy overload, the government does not seem to care to work on something like Bus Rapid Transit System (BRTS), which will cost less than one twentieth of Metro Rail and allow Indian geniuses to develop to serve. With current prices and sliding rupee-US dollar parity, comparative statements for various modes of mass transits are presented. It is obvious that BRTS should be priority one followed by the Sky Bus. Construction time is also indicated, considering that a highly stressed Mumbai transport infrastructure will not be significantly further stretched during construction phase. Mumbai has to be functional even as infrastructure projects are taken up for implementation. |
| riteshexpert | Konkan Railway to run special trains for Onam, Ganpati festivals on : September 11, 2013 - 05:56:02 AM |
|
MANGALORE: Konkan Railway will run unreserved special trains between Ratnagiri and Roha during Ganpati Festival and between New Delhi and Kochuveli during Onam festival to clear extra rush of passengers.Trains 05009/05010 Ratnagiri - Roha unreserved passenger will run on September 11, 15, 16 and 19 Train 05010 Ratnagiri - Roha train will leave from Ratnagiri at 6.50am and reach Roha at 12.50 pm same day. Train 05009 Roha - Ratnagiri will leave from Roha at 3.30pm and reach Ratnagiri at 9pm same day. The special trains will have total 12 coaches.Train 040906 New Delhi - Kochuveli Superfast Express will leave from New Delhi at 11.30pm on September 12 and will reach Kochuveli at 2:45am on fourth day. Train 040906 Kohcuveli - New Delhi will leave from Kochuveli at 9.40 am on September 17 and will reach New Delhi at 3.20pm on the third day.The special trains will halt at New Delhi, Mathura, Sawai Madhopur, Kota, Nagda, Ratlam, Dahod, Godhara, Vadodara, Bharuch, Surat, Navsari, Valsad, Vapi, Vasai Road, Panvel, Roha, Chiplun, Ratnagiri, Sindhudurg, Pernem, Madgaon, Karwar, Udupi, Manglore Jn, Kasargod, Kannur, Kozhikode, Tirur, Shoranur Jn., Thrisur, Aluva, Ernakulam Town, Kottayam, Tiruvalla, Chengannur, Kayankulam, Quilon, Kochuveli. The train will have 15 coaches. |
| riteshexpert | पंजाब से आईआरसीटीसी की पहली पर्यटन रेल on : September 11, 2013 - 05:56:25 AM |
|
पंजाब से आईआरसीटीसी की पहली पर्यटन रेल 15 सिंतबर को अमृतसर से गोवा के लिए सुबह रवाना होगी। इसमें स्लीपर क्लास का चार्टड कोच होगा, जिसमें 70 पर्यटक अमृतसर टू गोवा के दर्शनीय स्थलों को पर्यटन का लुत्फ उठाएंगे। यह जानकारी आईआरसीटीसी अधिकारी शुभम आर्य ने दी। |
| railenquiry | Railways collects 95K in fines on : September 11, 2013 - 05:56:38 AM |
|
PUNE: The Pune railway division has penalised 911 commuters for littering, at the Pune Railway Station and inside trains, during the first five months of the current fiscal. |
| Jitendar | ट्रैक पर गंदगी से भड़के डिप्टी सीसीएम on : September 11, 2013 - 05:56:54 AM |
|
मीरजापुर : उत्तर मध्य रेलवे इलाहाबाद जोन के डिप्टी सीसीएम मुदित चंद्रा ने सोमवार को स्थानीय स्टेशन का निरीक्षण किया। इस दौरान उन्होंने ट्रैक पर पड़ी गंदगी देख नाराजगी जताई। उन्होंने कहा कि नियमित साफ-सफाई का अभियान चलाकर स्टेशन परिसर को साफ-सुथरा रखा जाए। |
| railgenie | Konkan Railway to run special trains for Onam, Ganpati festivals on : September 11, 2013 - 06:00:03 AM |
|
MANGALORE: Konkan Railway will run unreserved special trains between Ratnagiri and Roha during Ganpati Festival and between New Delhi and Kochuveli during Onam festival to clear extra rush of passengers.Trains 05009/05010 Ratnagiri - Roha unreserved passenger will run on September 11, 15, 16 and 19 Train 05010 Ratnagiri - Roha train will leave from Ratnagiri at 6.50am and reach Roha at 12.50 pm same day. Train 05009 Roha - Ratnagiri will leave from Roha at 3.30pm and reach Ratnagiri at 9pm same day. The special trains will have total 12 coaches.Train 040906 New Delhi - Kochuveli Superfast Express will leave from New Delhi at 11.30pm on September 12 and will reach Kochuveli at 2:45am on fourth day. Train 040906 Kohcuveli - New Delhi will leave from Kochuveli at 9.40 am on September 17 and will reach New Delhi at 3.20pm on the third day.The special trains will halt at New Delhi, Mathura, Sawai Madhopur, Kota, Nagda, Ratlam, Dahod, Godhara, Vadodara, Bharuch, Surat, Navsari, Valsad, Vapi, Vasai Road, Panvel, Roha, Chiplun, Ratnagiri, Sindhudurg, Pernem, Madgaon, Karwar, Udupi, Manglore Jn, Kasargod, Kannur, Kozhikode, Tirur, Shoranur Jn., Thrisur, Aluva, Ernakulam Town, Kottayam, Tiruvalla, Chengannur, Kayankulam, Quilon, Kochuveli. The train will have 15 coaches. |
| irmafia | Three Weekly Special Trains between Kamakhya (Guwahati) - Chennai Central, Kamakhya (Guwahati) - Yes on : September 11, 2013 - 06:00:06 AM |
|
Three Weekly special trains, between Kamakhya (Guwahati) -Chennai Central & between Kamakhya (Guwahati) -Yesvantpur and between Santragachi-Kochuveli will be run in order to clear extra rush of passengers during Durga Pooja / Diwali festival as per the following schedule:- |
| Mafia | Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) named interim consultant for Lucknow Metro project on : September 11, 2013 - 06:00:12 AM |
|
Lucknow: The Uttar Pradesh government Tuesday appointed Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) as its “interim consultant” for launching the Metro Rail project in the state capital, officials said.The decision was taken at a state cabinet meeting presided over by Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav.Both Rites and DMRC have been asked to submit proposals by sending them terms of reference, an official said and added that for the said work, Rites has submitted a proposal of Rs.19.5 crore excluding service tax while DMRC submitted a Rs.13 crore proposal excluding the tax.“Since the DMRC proposal was financially lesser, the state cabinet approved it,” the official told IANS.DMRC, a joint venture of the railway ministry and the Delhi government, has been involved in the spadework for the Lucknow Metro Rail project and had earlier prepared a detailed project report (DPR) for it.As interim consultants, DMRC would carry out an action plan to select a general consultant, prepare a detailed report on land acquisition for the project, prepare an environment impact assessment report and chalk out a a rehabilitation policy, carry out on-spot surveys for the underground rail lines among others. |
| greatindian | कलुंगा में एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन ठहराव पर प्रदर्शन on : September 11, 2013 - 06:00:29 AM |
|
सुंदरगढ़ जिले के सबसे पुराने रेलवे स्टेशन कलुंगा में एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन के ठहराव की मांग को लेकर राजगांगपुर युवा कांग्रेस की ओर से प्रदर्शन किया गया तथा स्टेशन मास्टर को चक्रधरपुर रेल मंडल प्रबंधक के नाम ज्ञापन सौंपा। उन्होंने लंबे अर्से से की जा रही मांग पर शीघ्र विचार नहीं करने पर आंदोलन तेज करने की चेतावनी दी है। |
| Mafia | Railways clear jatropha bio-diesel for field trials on : September 11, 2013 - 07:56:04 AM |
|
AHMEDABAD: Research Design Standard Organisation (RDSO), the research wing of Indian Railways, has cleared Jatropha bio-diesel developed by Central Salt Marine & Chemical Research Institute for field trials in locomotives."RDSO has cleared Jatropha bio-diesel of CSMCRI for field trials in locomotives. A few more approvals are required and possibly in next 3-4 months we shall commence the trials on two locomotives in Jetalsar," a Western Railway official said."During initial trials it would be 10 per cent bio-diesel and 90 per cent conventional diesel, but as we progress the bio-diesel content will be scaled up," he said.Railways use diesel-run locomotives on several routes where electric lines are yet to be laid. Jetalsar (Rajkot district) to Dhasa (Amreli district) is one such line."Laboratory tests have been conducted to test locomotives on B-100 bio-diesel (neat bio-diesel), but there are some issues with it. Hopefully once resolved, we aim to run the locomotives on hundred per cent bio-diesel," the official said.CSMCRI Director Dr Pushpito Ghosh said, "Yes, our bio-diesel has been cleared for field trials by the RDSO."Jatropha biodiesel can be produced for between Rs 45-65 per litre assuming all-inclusive dry fruit cost of Rs 8,000 per tonne," an institute official said.Earlier, the institute's US patented technology to extract bio-diesel from Jatropha was successfully adopted by Vehicle Research Development Establishment, a defence laboratory in Ahmednagar to run a few vehicles on this environment-friendly fuel. |
General Discussion
|
|
PNR Predictions
|
|
Train Discussion
|
|
Feedback
|
Indian Railways News
|
